Why I Never Use Fresh Bread in My Thanksgiving Stuffing

FOODCOOKINGEDITOR'S PICKS

Jason Decker

11/16/20264 min read

Jason Decker develops and tests recipes at This Silly Girl's Kitchen, where he has published more than 1,500 tested comfort food recipes.

I learned very quickly that fresh bread ruins stuffing. I took the first bite, and it was a soggy disaster.

This was Thanksgiving, so this was game day for me. To have my stuffing be a complete soggy mess was a gigantic letdown for me and for all the people we had at our Thanksgiving party.

The most ambitious Thanksgiving I ever had

It was four years ago. I decided to cook turkeys three ways: oven-baked, smoked, and fried. That was the year I had coworkers over who didn't have family in town, so I had a sizable group of people.

Nobody said anything about the stuffing, and they didn't need to. I could tell by their body language, and by the fact that at the end of the meal there was a full tray of stuffing. Except for a couple of dents out of it, nobody went back for seconds. Nobody asked to take any home in a to-go plate.

What fresh bread does in the pan

Fresh bread goes into the pan soft. It soaks up the stock and turns to paste before it ever gets the chance to brown. What you get is a bread soup, which is not what you want on Thanksgiving Day.

Dried bread is different. It soaks up all that stock and still holds its shape.

The next year, I toasted the bread

The next time I made stuffing, I decided to toast the bread, and it was the best decision I made. It was crispy, it was crunchy, it held its form. You knew it was stuffing. Having it infused with the stock and egg brought extra flavor to it, and with the texture from the toasting, it was absolutely delicious.

That year we ran out of stuffing. There were no to-go plates. Everybody ate all the stuffing that was there.

How I dry the bread

I've used both French bread and sourdough bread. I prefer French bread. I cube it and toast it the night before, because I want to make sure it has plenty of time to dry out. I toast it at 200 degrees for 30 minutes, in a single layer on sheet trays, stirring every 10 minutes. For me, that is the sweet spot. It comes out golden brown, dry, and crisp, and it has great texture and flavor.

If you have the time, you can also leave the cubes out overnight and let them go stale on their own. Either way, the goal is the same. The bread has to be dry before it meets the stock.

How do you know it's dry enough? Pick up a cube and squeeze it. It should feel hard and crisp, like a crouton, and it shouldn't give at all. Then break one in half. If the center is still soft or spongy, it needs more time. Put the tray back in the oven for another 10 minutes and check again.

If you went the overnight route, the cubes should feel light and sound hollow when you tap them together. If any of them still feel soft in the middle, toast them for a few minutes before you mix in the stock.

The ten-minute soak

Once the bread is dry, I mix two eggs into the stock and pour it over the bread cubes and the vegetables. Then I let it sit for 10 minutes so the bread can absorb the liquid. It should be very moist, but not wet.

How much stock

I use three cups of unsalted chicken stock, and it works out great. There is still a crispiness and a texture to it. You could easily think three cups would be too much. It's not. In my opinion it's the perfect amount and the perfect balance, giving the stuffing softness while still keeping the crispy texture in every bite.

If you like your stuffing drier, start with two cups and add the third only if it looks dry after the soak.

What makes it taste like Thanksgiving

What makes the stuffing taste like Thanksgiving is the stock. It's what gives the stuffing that Thanksgiving flavor. The butter, celery, onion, garlic, sage, thyme, and poultry seasoning all marry together and release their flavors into the bread, making each bite delicious.

In the bird and in the dish

I make enough stuffing to fill the cavity of the turkey and still have enough for an 11 by 7 dish. I love it when the stuffing in the turkey has all those flavors in it. It tastes absolutely incredible.

If you stuff your bird, check the stuffing in the center with a thermometer. It needs to reach 165 degrees to be safe to eat.

The dish is where you get the crunch. I cover it with foil and bake it at 350 for 40 minutes, then take the foil off and bake it another 20 to 30 minutes until it's golden brown and crispy on top.

The girls own the mashed potatoes

My daughters, Maddie and Lizzie, have both improved dramatically with their cooking skills. Now the girls are very active with the mashed potatoes, which in our family is the crown jewel of all sides.

They definitely have plenty of opinions. I don't even need to ask. They provide them to me free of charge, early and often.

If you only remember one thing

If you are making stuffing for the first time this Thanksgiving, I would tell you 100% to toast the bread. It's the best decision there is to make sure your stuffing is still crisp and looks like stuffing, instead of a bread soup.

The full recipe I make for Classic Stuffing every year is here.

Related Stories